“We Shall Overcome” – An Account of an Arrest at the Tar Sands Action

Why I am coming to DC — admin August 26, 2011 at 10:45 am

Adam Maynard was part of the Tar Sands Action on August 21st – this is his story of participating, and the power of civil disobedience to change the world. To join him, sign up here.

Sir, step forward please.”

A buff mustachioed officer of the DC Park Police motioned me to come closer. I’ll never forget his next four words, “You are under arrest.” He then told me to turn around and snapped thick plastic bands around my wrists.

I was the third-to-last of 59 participants in civil disobedience earlier today to be arrested at the White House. We were taking nonviolent direct action in opposition to the proposed Keystone XL Pipeline, which would bring tar sands oil from Alberta, Canada to the US Gulf Coast. Aside from the danger this pipeline would pose to sources of drinking water, rural and indigenous peoples, and wildlife, if this carbon were to enter the atmosphere it would be game over for climate. Estimates place the tar sands contribution to CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere at 600 parts per million (ppm), so this pipeline is kind of a big deal. For reference, 350 ppm is the concentration at which human life on Earth developed. We’re currently somewhere between 385 and 395 ppm CO2, and steadily climbing.

After each of us was pulled from the rest of group lined up along the sidewalk, we were led into a small tent and then loaded into a paddy wagon to be transported to the Anacostia branch of the Park Police for further processing. I was loaded into the last truck along with Jerome from New Jersey and Bishop from Virginia. To say we were cramped would be an understatement. Imagine bouncing around in the back of a mobile toaster. Then imagine having your hands behind your back, and you’ll get a sense of our experience. I was first on the transport so I had a view out of the front of the vehicle through the metal mesh between myself and the driver. As we wove through the streets of DC behind our motorcycle escort past the White House, through the Mall beside the Washington Monument, and across the Anacostia River, I wondered what the tourists were thinking. What’s all this ruckus? Who are these criminals being transported across town? I could see them turning their heads along the sidewalks as they heard the whine of the sirens coming down the street. I chuckled to myself. If only they knew that behind the windowless walls of the truck sat a recent college graduate, an environmental engineer, and a lawyer who’d all been demonstrating at the White House only moments before. We’re doing this for you, I thought, and we’re doing this for each other.

Processing once we arrived at the jailhouse was relatively painless. One by one they snapped off our plastic cuffs and led us to a long table staffed with officers who had us fill out paperwork for our release. Because of the low severity of our crime – we were charged with failure to obey a lawful order (aka get off the sidewalk) – and the benevolence of the Park Police, we were granted a “post and forfeit” release. Under these terms we could pay a $100 fine instead of staying overnight in jail and arranging a date in court. Thankfully we were instructed to have cash on us beforehand, and we were all out of police custody by 2:00 or so. Not so bad considering arrests had started around 11:30. I also want to make a point of saying that the DC Park Police were courteous and professional throughout the process, and I hope they spend my $100 wisely.

One of the most remarkable things for me about this action was the ability of a group of complete strangers to come together and rally around a common vision. It was even more astonishing to me that part of that goal was arrest. Action organizers affectionately used the phrase “risking arrest” when describing the action we were to take but after three previous days of arrested participants we had a good idea of what we were in for. The vast majority of us, like myself, were first-time participants in a demonstration of this kind and had never been arrested before. This could have made for a nervous bunch, but after spending several hours at a civil disobedience training session last night we were comfortable enough to put our trust in one another and take this leap of faith together. Leading up to the action I was anxious about entering into a scenario where I wasn’t in control of my personal well-being (wait, you mean we’re actually going to be arrested, like arrested arrested?), but as soon as I showed up at the White House this morning I knew that I would be in good hands – those of the wonderful, courageous, and passionate people who had come from all over the country to stand beside me. I realized too that sometimes you must relinquish that control in order to take control of something you care about.

One of the most memorable moments from today was when my buddy (we each had action buddies who were our go-to’s for support throughout the day) Lawrence MacDonald and others led us in a variation of We Shall Overcome, an anthem of the Civil Rights movement. The lyrics drew nicely on the essence of what we were trying to accomplish:

We shall heal the earth, we shall heal the earth,
We shall heal the earth someday;
Oh, deep in my heart, I do believe,
We shall heal the earth someday.

If today showed me anything, it’s that this day is coming and we can get there even quicker if we work together to oppose injustice and bring positive change to the world.

Final note: Infinite thanks to the Tar Sands Action organizing team. Your help in preparing us for what we could expect throughout the day and your presence before, during, and after the action were invaluable to this experience. It honestly wouldn’t have been possible, and won’t continue to be possible this next week and a half, without your tireless work. I’m exhausted after participating in a single day, I can’t imagine the resolve it must take to be out there day after day training a new group and seeing them safely through the arrest process. I think I speak for all of those who participated with me today when I say you are the real heroes of this action. Thank you!

Post to Twitter

  • LIZ

    DEAR ADAM , I AM SO GRATEFUL FOR YOU AND YOUR”BUDDIES’ ACTIONS. I FEEL YOUR PASSION FOR THE CAUSE THROUGH YOUR WRITING AND IT MOTIVATES AND MOVES ME AS I AM SURE IT DOES OTHERS. THANK YOU FOR TAKING THE TIME TO WRITE ABOUT THIS EXPERIENCE,THOSE OF US JOINING IN THE UPCOMING DAYS SHOULD FEEL INSPIRED. AGAIN THANK YOU FOR YOUR ACTIONS.

  • GL

    Action occurs on both sides of the country! Last night, in Moscow, Idaho, protesters blocked the street where a megaload (equipment bound for the tars sands) was passing. The load was slowed and a few protesters were arrested.

  • EJ

    i don’t really think it’s quite fair to compare this to the civil rights movement

  • Anonymous

    Actually, it is more important than the civil rights movement.
    DaveW

  • EJ

    if that’s a joke, it’s in extremely poor taste

    in this demonstration, no one was injured, no dogs were set on anyone, there have been no examples of police brutality (as far as i have seen). no women have been raped, no children have been killed, etc

    i’m not saying this isn’t an important issue–it’s certainly a very important issue, and i commend everyone who has participated for what they have done. but you can’t compare it to the civil rights movement, let alone tastelessly rank it by “importance”.

  • LIZ

    Dear EJ – I feel that it doesn’t of course compare to the brutal ways in which people were treated during the civil rights movement. I lived through them as a child, but the comparison is based on the passion and the inner self saying this is what I must do , no matter what may happen to me. This inner light and strength and will, was present back then. Thanks to Martin Luther King and that movement we can have peaceful demonstration{ unfortunately still risk arrest} we are standing up against the odds and we are united. That is a wonderful thing ,just like the civil rights marches,that brought us together.

  • http://www.swiftpat.com PAT Testing

    Intresting comments.

  • JH

    I’m not sure I understand this action’s take on arrestability. Are y’all trying to fill the jails? I’d think that would be a good way to go about it…hundreds of people getting arrested has a lot of impact, but certainly a more intensely-felt one if the jails are overcrowded, putting pressure on the “justice” system. Also, what’s the immediate goal of the action? (legitimately curious, here, not criticizing–it sounds like there’s an amazing amount of organization!) Is it to disrupt business as usual and get people inconvenienced as much as we can? Keep it rolling! Wish I could be there!

  • Imaginatyves

    For once that so many left wing organizations have rallied in this cause (rather than the usual knifing in the back), let’s not start a silly, useless argument.

  • Leslie

    I really appreciate what you wrote. I, too, have never been arrested and have been nervous. You have put my fear to rest – I am coming Sept. 3 with my son – and I am pumped!

  • Jesse

    A couple of points from someone who participated in the action (I’m the other guy getting arrested in the photo above). We actually talked about a question similar to this in the paddy wagon, namely how lucky we were to know that we weren’t going to be beaten, “disappeared,” shot, tortured, or any of the other risks faced by many civil disobedience actions, whether during the civil rights movement, Gandhi’s satyagraha, or the ongoing protests in places like Syria. Our intent was not to suggest that our actions be compared to those in courage or consequence, but rather to evoke that tradition as a means of honoring it.

    As for the stakes themselves, the magnitude of the climate question is genuinely unthinkable, so I do think that the “importance” of the movement is difficult to overstate. However, we are both aware and grateful for the fact that it is the far greater courage displayed by others in the face of genuine violence that makes a movement like this one possible.

    It will be a long, hard road to a green economy, one that will require nothing less than reimagining what it means to be modern. In that struggle, protesting is the easy part.

  • FF

    I support you 100%. I can’t be there in person, but I’m writing to the President every day.

    FF

  • Lpaigeg

    Well said jesse!

  • Dan M’Naughten

    Hey Leslie,

    Did you know that buying conflict oil from Saudi Arabia (14% of total US imports) supports a totalitarian regime which routinely abuses human rights by mistreating women, GLBT, journalists and others (http://www.amnestyusa.org/our-work/countries/middle-east-and-north-africa/saudi-arabia)?

    So, maybe you and your son should be protesting against the importation of conflict oil from Saudi Arabia.

    Better yet, why don’t you go to Riyadh and protest against these human rights violations.

    That way you’d for sure get arrested . . . and tortured . . . and probably sent to jail for decades (or maybe even executed).

  • Dan M’Naughten

    Hey Adam,

    When you refer to your junk science about CO2 emissions, don’t forget to mention that:

    > Every week, in China, two newly constructed coal-fired power plants fire up (and even if China’s building much smaller plants — ones emitting between one and two million tonnes, say — at a rate of two new plants a week, that means the Chinese are adding an annual greenhouse gas burden to the world’s atmosphere of somewhere between 100 and 200 million tonnes, or megatonnes, every year. If the plants are large ones, that number could be several hundred megatonnes of carbon dioxide being pushed out every single year).
    > The largest coal-fired power plant in the world, in Taiwan, emits about 42 megatonnes of carbon dioxide every year.
    >Some of the biggest U.S. plants each put out between 16 million and 25 million tonnes per year.

    The entire oilsands industry emits, every year, 45 MT . . . and has reduced its GHG output by 29% since 1990.

    OK?!

    Why aren’t you protesting in front of the coal mines? Or the coal-fired generating plants? Or lobbying President Obama to stop coal exports from the US?

    Wny??!

  • Monarch

    Amen! I remember a phone call from a member of the legal team after I had safely returned from police custody. She just wanted to be sure I was OK.

    Hope this is the “refusal to go to the back of the bus” type action that will kick start a nation wide movement away from fossil fuel! What’s the next step—while we are mobilized?

  • Chris1stone

    Thank you for doing this, thank you for standing by your beliefs. In the 60′s I took my kids to Viet Nam war protests, married as I was to a Navy pilot. We were watched, for sure, but not harassed.
    At 70 it is your turn, and thank you for stepping up to the plate, for all of us, for the planet, and every non-human being as well.

  • Chris1stone

    GO Moscow! and hopefully to Janet my old neighbor and gal friend from Whidbey, the poet, and so much more.

  • Angela

    Beautiful and very well said. Thank you Tar Sand Action team and all those participating! I’m seriously in awe of you all! Wish I was there to get arrested with you!

  • Anner

    This is happening in Ireland also where oil is paying local oficials to use public lands for private gains.

  • Lawrence MacDonald

    EJ: Jesse and I were in the paddy wagon together, and I’m the one who suggested we sing “We Shall Overcome.” He expresses my views exactly.

    I was in fact a little reluctant to invoke the great Civil Rights anthem, precisely because I worried that some people would feel we were expropriating the legacy of Dr. King. And it’s true that we have not (yet, at least) been faced with anything like the oppression and violence that confronted the Civil Rights activists.

    But we are deeply and legitimately inspired by Dr. King and his legacy and the battle in which we are engaged will ultimatey be crucial to the survival of our civilization, regardless of skin color. So invoking King, and We Shall Overcome seems entirely appropriate. Besides, it’s a great song! : )

  • Barbara

    The immediate goal of this action is to pressure the Obama administration into denying a permit for the Keystone XL pipeline. As the president prepares for the dedication of the Martin Luther King monument, commemorating someone who courageously used civil disobedience to further the cause of social justice and equality, it would hard for Obama not to see how this action echoes the sentiments of the days of the civil rights movement. While this action was tame(I, too, was arrested) in comparison to what the black people and civil rights workers endured during the 60′s, the message is still the same. We want a better world and a future for our children’s children. This will not be possible if CO2 emissions aren’t drastically reduced.

  • Marydecker

    Many thanks to Adam Maynard for posting the detailed description of his arrest experience. Now I have a better idea of what to expect when I participate in the protest on September 2nd. Also, I appreciate Adam calling attention to the professional and courteous way in which the National Park Police handled our protesters. That was a very thoughtful gesture on his part that I am sure the Park police will appreciate.

  • JH

    Sounds awesome. Are you lobbying for a meeting with the President or someone in the White House? When’s the deadline for the permit? I wish I could make it to D.C! But we’ll have to keep up our support here on the West Coast…

  • Moran

    Thank you for participating in this civil disobedience to stop the Tar Sands Pipeline.
    One note though: paddy wagon (though still in wide usage) is considered by some as an ethnic slur against the Irish (paddy being an old nickname for an Irishman and paddy wagons were used to pick up drunks, stereotypically despised Irish immigrants) … I said it once as a teenager (I had no clue as to its origin) and my dad (a child of Irish immigrants who was born in the 20′s) got really upset and told me never to use that phrase again. Just a suggestion to change your wording to police wagon.

  • Lawrence MacDonald

    Thanks. I had no idea that this was considered a slur by some. I’ll refrain from using it in the future. Though a quick check on Wikipedia shows a number of possible derivations, the first having to do not with Irish (supposedly) being drunks but with the fact that Irish made up a large proportion of the early police force in American cities. (or maybe it was about the padding).

  • Jps

    but is that it? you get arrested pay a fine and you’ve done your bit? so now you have to go back and get arrested again right? why did you pay the fine? isn’t that admitting guilt? why didn’t you let the people know who was in the back of the police van by chanting or singing? it seems to me you were extremely obedient.

  • http://www.convergenceenergetique.org Framboise

    Dear Asam, dear friends of all around the world. I’m writing this bill from France, where it has been said that Fracking was forbidden. It is but there is not any application decret yet so that big oil and gas companies will begin to drill in september or october in many parts of France. Will they frack? It’s impossible to say.
    Anyway there was a big citizen rally in the south of France and 15 000 people were there to bring testimonies from all Europe, and to have a big reflexion about energetic transition. We are at your side for this terrible fight against tar sands, Keystone pipeline, and shale gas. We say no to all those abominations ant pray for a healthy future for the planet. Thanks Adam for having endured this arrest. You don’t make it in vain and all the planet has eyes on you. Je vous embrasse

  • Moran

    My dad (son, born in 1925 of Irish immigrants and growing up in what was then a WASP-run town of Quincy MA) had an instantaneous and visceral negative reaction when I said the word “paddy wagon” as a teenager in the 1980′s. So for him and his family – there was only one intended meaning of the word “paddy wagon” and that was to describe (stereotypically of course) the drunks in the back. His immigrant dad was a fire fighter and he had an immigrant uncle who was a cop. But those who controlled the town and schools and banks and power and media were definitely not immigrants. There was a lot of anti-immigrant feelings then just as there is today in places like Arizona. Despite the number of possible derivations, given my dad’s reaction I have no doubt the term is a residual of bigotry.

  • Moran

    And thank you for deciding not to use the term. I haven’t used it for the last 25 years since I learned the meaning.

  • Moran

    Thank you for participating in this civil disobedience to stop the Tar Sands Pipeline.
    One note though: paddy wagon (though still in wide usage) is considered by some as an ethnic slur against the Irish (paddy being an old nickname for an Irishman and paddy wagons were used to pick up drunks, stereotypically despised Irish immigrants) … I said it once as a teenager (I had no clue as to its origin, thought it meant padded wagon) and my dad (a child of Irish immigrants who was born in the 20′s) got really upset and told me never to use that phrase again as it is a slur against the Irish. Just a suggestion to change your wording to police wagon or padded wagon (if it is indeed padded? I’ve never been in one). Thank you for your consideration. I thought it appropriate since you are discussing civil rights as well as the environment.


(c) 2012 Tar Sands Action | powered by WordPress