Tim DeChristopher is going to jail. Now it’s our turn.

News — admin July 27, 2011 at 12:56 am

This article from Bill McKibben has been cross-posted from the Huffington Post. To join Bill and hundreds of others in the action against Keystone XL tar sands pipeline, sign up here: http://www.tarsandsaction.org/sign-up/

“The idea of wilderness needs no defense. It only needs more defenders.” –Ed Abbey

“The Eyes of the Future are looking back at us and they are praying for us to see beyond our own time.” –Terry Tempest Williams

There’s something about the redrock canyons that seems to inspire great writing — I was lucky enough to know Ed Abbey and to count Terry Tempest Williams as a great friend. Both wrote — and both fought. They fulfilled the duty they owed that great landscape. They fought to protect great chunks of land

And they’re joined by Tim DeChristopher, sentenced today to 24 months in prison for a creative act of resistance straight out of the Monkey Wrench Gang. He didn’t damage anything except the pride of the Bureau of Land Management, when he posed as a bidder and won 14 parcels of land at an oil-and-gas lease auction. They were gorgeous pieces of land that he protected — but far more, he was acting on behalf of every landscape left on the planet.

Because the oil and gas under that ground needs to stay there. The carbon it contains is, we now know, ruinous — it’s what is heating the atmosphere, setting new temperature records every day. If you sweated through last week’s record heat, if your crops are withering in the southwest’s epic drought, if you watched the Mississippi swallow your town — then Tim DeChristopher acted for you.

And it’s time for you to take the same kind of responsibility. In a few weeks, those of us at tarsandsaction.org will be gathering in Washington DC for two weeks of civil disobedience against the proposed Keystone Pipeline, that will carry oil from the tar sands of Alberta down to the Gulf of Mexico. Jim Hansen, the NASA climatologist, says that if those tar sands are fully exploited it’s “essentially game over for the climate.” If those words don’t inspire you to act, nothing will — and so far more than a thousand have signed on, meaning this will be the largest civil disobedience action in the history of the country’s climate movement.

This action won’t be as risky as Tim’s. People are signing up to come to DC for three days. On the first they’ll attend nonviolence training, and on the second they’ll sit down in front of the White House. No one knows for sure how the police will react, but the legal experts say jail time will likely be measured in hours, not years. Still, it’s a very real way to say to President Obama (who will make the Keystone decision all by himself) that this is the great moral issue of our time.

DeChristopher acted before he wrote. But he’s a writer too — in court he read an essay before his sentencing, which ended with these words about civil disobedience:

“At this point of unimaginable threats on the horizon, this is what hope looks like. In these times of a morally bankrupt government that has sold out its principles, this is what patriotism looks like. With countless lives on the line, this is what love looks like, and it will only grow.”

I think he’s right.

Post to Twitter

  • Oredoc1

    As a child of the 60′ and 70′s I have only one piece of advice, and then my whole committment is with you, in spirit and belief if not body. The lesson we learned was do not become worse in the public eye than what you are protesting! Let the focus remain on what you want not what you are doing!

  • David Slesinger

    Oredoc1′s comment could have merit. If he means that while people are protesting or in court or in jail that they address the environmental threat rather than their own inconvenience, I agree. If he means that we should avoid civil disobedience and be only about pure public education, I don’t agree.

    I am the first person to serve time for a sentence for civil disobedience on the climate change issue. That was for only 16 hours in July of 2009 over the building of the Cliffside Coal plant in North Carolina. I pleaded guilty and told the judge I didn’t seek mercy. The judge told the jailer to treat me with kid gloves because I was a friend of his.

    I have met with Mike Tidwell, the founder of Chesapeake Climate Action Network. We had a good talk. Ted Glick, the person most experienced in nonviolence at CCAN, refuses to talk to me. I don’t mind if people disagree with me. I do mind when advocates of nonviolence won’t discuss the potential for greater power with Gandhi’s approach to resistance.

    Gandhi’s approach is really too stringent for most westerners. It would be unreasonable and unfair to suggest Gandhi’s approach be the only option for those willing to do civil disobedience. It would be sad if our important and growing movement suppress discussion of how we can be more powerful.

    The Tarsands action described above has a lot about it worthy of praise.

    I plead with Bill McKibben to begin this discussion with me. dslesinger@alum.mit.edu

    Dave

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Wits-End/100002383345709 Wit’s End

    Bravo! The entire statement to the court is copied here: http://witsendnj.blogspot.com/2011/07/statement-to-court-by-tim-dechristopher.html

    with a video of his speech to PowerShift 2011.

  • Monica

    wish you would say a bit more to make your meaning clearer — thx.

  • Monica

    it would be nice to have such a discussion in a public forum ~ about process and how we demonstrate/communicate intention. Given what I’ve seen of videos from demonstrations of late, before I participate in one I would want to know ahead of coming what the commitments are, and how folks who might have other agendas or who might act out disrespectfully, aggressively mid stream, are going to be screened out. These are tense situations, and I for one no longer want to be in actions where some one, is behaving in ways designed to incite wrath or violence that will be received by a group that is being nonviolent/pacifistic. There is great diversity of opinion on this, and there are plenty of folks who think its fine to “use” a nvda as a forum when they are planning on using a “full range of actions” and think its unfair censorship to define an action as nvda…..

  • http://kaitembird.wordpress.com/ Kait Mauro

    This strikes me as good advice, thank you.

  • Anonymous

    I appreciate your honesty.

  • Anonymous

    In what respect?

  • Rene’

    Environmental Law, Constitution Preamble… just thinking out loud here

  • http://twitter.com/jbbravo jbbravo

    I’m not a huge fan of civil disobedience as jail-time seems a bit unappealing. Why can’t we take all this energy and shove into the legislative government and invoke real change. Why do I think that we’re not truly displaying Ghandi’s non-violence, this seems more like civil partial violence. Getting all of America to write to their representation seems like a real winner…

  • Anonymous

    Of course jail is unappealing, but civil disobedience is a principled, legitimate expression of discontent. Unfortunately, we know that writing our representatives won’t be enough on this – too many of them have been deeply compromised by the influence of oil money in elections – and we need to do what’s right by the nonviolent means available to us.

  • Anonymous

    Everyone who participates in this action will be part of a training the night before which will help us work through many of these questions. There will be people of varying experiences in this event, and we’re being sure that each day there are people equipped to defuse confrontation and speak clearly to the media at the event.

  • http://twitter.com/LuckyLeilani Leilani

    As an environmental scientist, I have a different perspective on this. Tim was an economics student posing as a bidder in a BLM auction of PUBLIC land to those interested in using OUR land for oil drilling and pipeline expansion. Tim bid and won but was found to have violated a FEDERAL law because he wasn’t a “legal” bidder and he had no intention to pay for the winnings. A federal grand jury is not held the same as a criminal jury. What happened is unjust. Even though the maximum penalty is 5 yrs and $250,000 fine, Tim was charged with 2 offenses; defrauding the American people for public land he did not intend to pay for is one of them.
    There’s not enough room to comment on all of the injustices I’ve uncovered but I will say that we must hold those who won the bids on the public leased lands accountable and make sure they don’t violate NEPA standards in their attempt to rape and pillage OUR land for oil and gas WE BUY to heat/cool our mini-mansion homes and drive our SUVs. For more info see page 3 of this BLM document http://on.doi.gov/oSIo06 – and think about WHY these lands went up for auction in the first place. Could it be due to our own stupidity and greed?

    Tar Sands in Canada contain the largest reserves of “oil” in the world. Canada has now replaced Saudi nations as the #1 supplier to the U.S. for petroleum. The extraction process is VERY harmful to the environment. It’s so thick in viscosity, it cannot be “piped” and must be mixed with other liquids, to make it thin enough travel. The temperatures from Canada to Texas grow warmer the further south the pipeline travels. If it’s thin enough to travel in Canada, imagine what the consistency will be like as it grows warmer by the time it reaches Texas? The extraction, the refinement of the “oil” and the subsequent use will add more than 45% of greenhouse gas emissions to our planet than traditional petroleum. The U.S. supply of petro peaked in 1971. The WORLD supply of petro is expected to peak in 2012. This means the supply of traditional petroleum will begin to DECREASE and we are forced to search for alternative resources to feed our growing consumption of oil and petro products made from it like plastic ~ that which we use to package products sold to us at Wal-Mart and grocery stores across the USA. THINK about it.
    Civil Disobedience is another issue. Since when has it been a crime to peaceably assemble? Do you know what your civil rights are? Read This! http://bit.ly/3PGBillOfRights – Do you realize that when any form of government impedes our rights to pursue Life, Liberty and Happiness, we can abolish it and create a new one? Read This! (in case you forgot) http://bit.ly/3PGLestWe4Get – We have rights guaranteed to all America’s citizens and we need to ensure those rights are protected.
    What Tim did was civil disobedience. No more illegal than Rosa Parks refusing to give up her seat on the bus. However, he violated FEDERAL law by challenging the BLM; an agency established to PROTECT public (yes, PUBLIC) lands. What we are doing here is freedom of speech and communicating what we know so that we can educate one another. Please share. Please educate yourself by reading the links and please GET INVOLVED! “None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free…”
    ~ Goethe

    More Links:
    Oil Sands http://bit.ly/pHwXGs
    Keystone Pipeline http://bit.ly/rtim4u
    HuffPo on Tim http://huff.to/nAYSwc and SLC Tribune on Tim http://bit.ly/pZ7WcO
    U.S. Energy and Security Act of 2007 http://bit.ly/n6cfdB
    U.S. Energy Policy Act of 2005 http://bit.ly/pAItAr
    Safer Separation and Extraction Method http://bit.ly/px4sKr

  • George Hoguet

    I will be at the DC sit-in, and plan to wear white – a symbol of surrender or truce – but also clearly the symbol of peace and nonviolence. I am not there to be angry and ugly, nor combative, but to help Wake Up the public. I invite others to do the same. I come to this action in peace on behalf of my children and grandchildren, indeed for children of all species, to support the White House in making the decision to stop this pending tragedy.

    In his 1849 essay, On the Duty of Civil Disobedience, Henry David Thoreau began the piece talking about his ideal vision that government would not be needed at all, but he then said ” But, to speak practically and as a citizen, unlike those who call themselves no-government men, I ask for, not at one no government, but at once a better government. Let every man make known what kind of government would command his respect, and that will be one step toward obtaining it. ” I view our actions in DC as a call to the White House to become the kind of government that can command our respect by taking leadership for the future of our earth on this Tar Sands issue.

    Please consider wearing white as a further way to express your commitment to nonviolence, to calmness and seriousness. Our presecence will speak loudly.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Wincenty.pawlowski Vincent Pawlowski

    I first head about the “enhanced greenhouse effect” 34 years ago. The time for teach-ins, talk, petitions, lobbying and banner waving is over. Committing my first act of civil disobedience after witnessing Tim DeChristopher’s sentencing left me feeling more empowered than ever. Please join us in joy and resolve in DC!

  • http://www.facebook.com/Wincenty.pawlowski Vincent Pawlowski

    If writing to our government representatives worked, climate change would have been fixed in the 1970′s, or at least in 2009. I welcome you to try that avenue. On my last climate justice tour, I marched on Blair Mountain, then lobbied congress with Citizens’ Climate Lobby. We can do both. We need to do everything, as it will take a lot to break through the denial. I advocate that everyone do SOMETHING!

  • jerusha

    Tim DeChristopher was convicted three days after the 165th anniversary of Thoreau’s night in the Concord jail, the night that sparked his defense of Civil Disobedience that continues to span continents and centuries.

    The trainings in preparation for the Tar Sands action (Get Down, Sit Down?) may give an opportunity for young activists to connect with veterans of the Civil Rights Movement (see http://crmvet.org). Whether it’s a commitment to a way of being in the world, or a commitment to a effective tactic for this action, a unified intention and voice will certainly magnify the impact.

  • David Slesinger

    Happy to see you enjoy having a perspective on civil disobedience.

    How do you feel about King’s phrase ” Undeserved suffering is redemptive.”?

    This action, like most American mass public arrests, assumes those arrested will serve zero or trivial time in jail. The logic that such a decision helps increase the numbers of participants has merit.

    Nevertheless, too often NONE of the participants in such actions hear the slightest about the idea that suffering to touch the hearts of the adversary has something to do with the power of nonviolence. I’m hardly worried that participants will be impolite, but I am concerned that avoiding suffering is a sign that our movement could care less about the opinions of the climate change deniers.


(c) 2012 Tar Sands Action | powered by WordPress